Definition:
Dual KPIs (Key Performance Indicators) are a strategic measurement system that pairs two distinct metrics to provide a more complete picture of performance. While traditional KPIs focus on a single outcome—like revenue, customer growth, or product quality—Dual KPIs track two related yet separate goals, such as balancing financial outcomes with social or environmental impact. This is especially relevant for purpose-driven and circular economy models, where both profitability and sustainability are critical to long-term success.
Mental Shortcut:
Imagine steering a ship: traditional KPIs are like focusing solely on speed, but Dual KPIs are like watching both speed and direction. Going fast (financial success) is pointless if you’re veering off course (ignoring sustainability or social impact).
Application:
Dual KPIs are increasingly used by organizations striving to balance financial goals with long-term sustainability. For example, a company might monitor profit margin alongside employee retention rates, ensuring the workforce is not sacrificed for higher profits. Another example is tracking net sales while reducing the company’s carbon footprint, ensuring growth doesn’t come at the environment’s expense.
Examples:
Patagonia: Patagonia tracks financial performance alongside its environmental and social impact. The company focuses on metrics such as reducing its carbon footprint, sustainable sourcing of materials, and fair labor practices. A real example of this dual focus can be seen in their decision to donate 1% of sales to environmental causes through their 1% for the Planet initiative. Their 2018 Patagonia Case Study shows how they have maintained profitability while championing environmental sustainability. Patagonia Case Study.
Unilever: Unilever tracks both financial and social/environmental KPIs through its Sustainable Living Plan. By 2020, 67% of Unilever’s products reduced environmental impact while maintaining strong financial growth. For example, their "Lifebuoy" soap campaign helped improve hygiene in developing countries while increasing sales. The company’s 2020 Sustainable Living Report demonstrates how it has improved revenue and minimized environmental impact. Unilever’s Sustainable Living Plan.
Ben & Jerry’s: This socially responsible ice cream company has consistently balanced profitability with social justice and environmental KPIs. Their “Caring Dairy” initiative supports sustainable farming practices while maintaining product quality and profitability. Ben & Jerry’s 2020 Social and Environmental Assessment Report outlines how they track revenue growth alongside key metrics like reduced energy usage and community support. Ben & Jerry’s SEAR.
Benefits:
Balanced decision-making: Helps leaders make informed choices by weighing both short-term wins and long-term outcomes.
Alignment with purpose: Drives company performance while staying true to the organization's mission and values.
Stakeholder engagement: Shows investors, consumers, and employees that the company cares about more than just financial success.
Improved resilience: Mitigates risk by diversifying focus, avoiding over-reliance on one-dimensional success metrics.
Challenges:
Complexity in balancing: Combining two different KPIs—like sustainability metrics with financial results—can create conflicting priorities.
Data integration hurdles: Gathering real-time data for two distinct KPIs can require advanced systems, which not all organizations have.
Cultural resistance: Teams may resist the dual focus, particularly if they are accustomed to prioritizing financial targets alone.
Short-termism pressure: There is often external pressure, especially from investors or board members, to prioritize short-term gains over long-term objectives. This tension can lead to sacrificing sustainable or social goals in favor of immediate financial results.
For instance, Unilever faced a challenge when its shift to sustainable packaging led to higher initial costs. However, by balancing sustainability with revenue targets, the company found long-term profitability through enhanced brand loyalty and operational efficiency. Unilever Packaging Initiative.
What Not to Do:
An example of failure in balancing Dual KPIs can be seen in the tech industry, where companies that prioritize user growth (financial KPI) without considering data privacy (non-financial KPI) can face significant backlash. Facebook experienced this with the Cambridge Analytica scandal, where prioritizing growth and advertising revenue over ethical data use led to a significant loss of public trust and financial penalties.
How to Start with Dual KPIs:
Define your values: Identify two dimensions that matter most to your organization (e.g., revenue growth and community engagement).
Align stakeholders: Ensure leadership and teams understand the importance of tracking both KPIs and how they will benefit the organization.
Coordinate across departments: Ensure that different departments (e.g., finance, sustainability, HR) are aligned with the goals, so all efforts push toward achieving both KPIs simultaneously.
Invest in tools: Use platforms that integrate financial and non-financial metrics (e.g., sustainability tracking software).
Regular reviews: Hold quarterly meetings to assess performance across both KPIs and adjust strategies accordingly.
Frameworks & Tools:
Balanced Scorecard: This well-established framework helps organizations pair financial outcomes with non-financial drivers such as innovation, customer satisfaction, and sustainability. Balanced Scorecard Review.
B Impact Assessment: This tool measures a company’s impact on its workers, community, environment, and customers, helping businesses track their progress toward holistic goals. Learn more at B Impact Assessment.
Global Reporting Initiative (GRI): A standard used by organizations to measure and report their sustainability impacts alongside financial performance. See more at GRI Standards.
Ecovadis: Provides sustainability ratings and performance reviews for global supply chains, helping companies align their sustainability and financial goals. More details at Ecovadis.
Related Terms:
Balanced scorecard, Triple bottom line, Impact measurement, Sustainability metrics, ESG reporting, Circular economy KPIs, Stakeholder capitalism, Long-term value creation
Sources and References:
Kaplan, Robert S., and David P. Norton. The Balanced Scorecard: Translating Strategy into Action. Harvard Business Review Press, 1996. Balanced Scorecard Reference
Patagonia's Environmental Responsibility: Patagonia Case Study
Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) Standards: GRI Standards
Unilever’s Sustainable Living Plan: Unilever Case Study
Ben & Jerry’s Social and Environmental Assessment Report: Ben & Jerry's SEAR
Comments